
Windermere Housing Market Report
September 2026
The Short Answer
What does the August 2026 Stellar MLS data mean for Windermere sellers heading into fall?
Windermere is not one pricing conversation. The market spans lower-priced resale, million-dollar homes, custom estates, gated communities, and high-end properties above $2.5 million, and those segments are behaving differently. The inventory currently under contract has a considerably shorter median market time than the overall active inventory, which reinforces the importance of price, property condition, community, lot, and competitive position. And because Windermere includes such a wide range of property types and price points, a single citywide median should be treated as context rather than a direct valuation tool for an individual property.
This Market Report Is Best For
- Windermere homeowners thinking about selling this fall
- Sellers trying to understand how different price tiers are behaving
- Anyone deciding whether their Windermere home is positioned correctly for today's market
This report analyzes the Windermere single-family listings contained in the supplied Stellar MLS dataset, including current active and pending inventory and August 2026 closed sales. Because Windermere includes a wide range of property types and price points, citywide statistics should be treated as market context rather than a direct valuation tool for an individual property.
When I pull numbers for Windermere, the first thing I have to remember is that this is not one market. It is several markets sitting inside the same city name. Lower-priced resale, million-dollar homes, custom estates, gated communities, and high-end properties above $2.5 million all behave differently, and a single citywide median can blur all of that together.
So this report is not a valuation tool. It is context. The numbers below show what the Windermere single-family dataset looks like right now, and the real pricing decision still has to be made property by property against the homes a buyer is actually comparing.
Windermere Market Snapshot
172
Active Listings
56
Pending Listings
43
August Closings
$1.395M
Median Active Asking
$960K
Median August Sale Price
95.2%
Avg Sale-to-List
Source: Stellar MLS. Data compiled September 2026.
The latest Windermere numbers
On the active side, there are currently 172 single-family listings in the Windermere dataset. The median asking price is $1,395,000, and the median cumulative days on market is 98.5 days.
On the pending side, there are 56 listings under contract. The median asking price is $777,500, and the median cumulative days on market is 42.5 days.
In August 2026, there were 43 closed sales. The median sale price was $960,000, the median cumulative days on market was 75 days, the median days to contract was 75 days, and the average sale to list ratio was 95.2%. The closed-sale range ran from approximately $460,000 to $3.9 million.
Source: Stellar MLS. Data compiled September 2026.
That range is part of the story. A market where August closings run from roughly $460,000 to $3.9 million is not a market where one median tells you what your home is worth. It is a market where the comp set matters more than the citywide number.
Why one Windermere median is not enough
The $960,000 August median is mathematically valid for the dataset. It is not a direct valuation benchmark for every Windermere property. The closed-sale range from approximately $460,000 to $3.9 million shows how broad the market is, and that range is exactly why a single median can be misleading.
Lakefront versus interior. Community. Lot type. Condition. Renovation level. Privacy. Custom versus production construction. Any of those can place two Windermere homes in completely different competitive sets, even when they share the same city name.
A lakefront home on the Butler Chain and an interior-lot home in a production subdivision are not competing for the same buyer in the same way. A fully renovated custom estate and an original-condition home with deferred maintenance may carry the same square footage, but buyers will not view them the same way. Citywide numbers are useful for context. They are not enough to tell you what your specific home is worth or how it should be positioned.
How the price tiers compare
The clearest way to see how different the Windermere segments are is to break the inventory into price tiers. The counts below show active, pending, and August closed sales for each band.
| Price Tier | Active | Pending | August Sold |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under $500K | 3 | 2 | 6 |
| $500K to $999K | 63 | 30 | 16 |
| $1M to $1.499M | 27 | 11 | 5 |
| $1.5M to $2.499M | 28 | 8 | 9 |
| $2.5M+ | 51 | 5 | 7 |
Source: Stellar MLS. Data compiled September 2026.
Most of the August activity occurred below $1 million, with 16 closings in the $500K to $999K band and 6 under $500K. The higher tiers show fewer pending and closed transactions relative to their active supply, which is part of why the comp set has to be read carefully at the upper end.
The $2.5 million and above segment
$2.5M+ Windermere Segment
Active Listings
51
Pending Listings
5
August Closings
7
The current dataset contains 51 active listings at $2.5 million and above, compared with 5 pending listings and 7 August closings. Those are the facts. I am not going to label this segment weak, oversupplied, slow, or a buyer's market from those counts alone. The higher-end market has a smaller pool of active transactions, and the right read on it requires looking at the specific homes buyers are comparing.
This is where broad citywide medians become less useful as properties become more unique. A seller at $2.5 million or above is not competing in the same market as a seller at $500,000, and the pricing analysis has to reflect that.
The gap between active and pending market time
When you put the three CDOM figures next to each other, a pattern shows up. Active inventory is sitting at a median of 98.5 cumulative days on market. Pending inventory is at 42.5 days. And the August closings closed at a median of 75 days.
How market time compares
Active
98.5
median cumulative days on market
Pending
42.5
median cumulative days on market
August Closings
75
median cumulative days on market
The inventory currently under contract has a considerably shorter median market time than the overall active inventory. That difference does not prove why any individual listing moved faster, but it reinforces the importance of price, property condition, community, lot, and competitive position.
Why property type matters more as price rises
At the lower price tiers, a Windermere home may compete fairly broadly against similar inventory. As the price rises, the comparisons get more specific, and the property type starts to matter more than the city name.
Butler Chain lakefront is a different property category from an interior lot. Even within waterfront, true chain frontage is different from canal-front. Gated golf communities, gated non-golf communities, custom estates, and non-gated neighborhoods each attract different buyers with different expectations for amenities, lot size, architecture, fees, and privacy.
Condition and renovation level create another layer. Two homes that look similar on paper can sit in very different positions once a buyer evaluates roof age, major systems, kitchens, baths, and deferred maintenance. I am not going to assign a generic dollar premium to lakefront or to any community feature. The right approach is to look for market evidence supporting those differences for the specific property, not to apply a formula. The Windermere market overview breaks down how those factors interact.
What I would watch as a Windermere seller
If I owned a home in Windermere, there are a few things I would be watching closely right now.
I would watch the direct active competition in the same property type. A lakefront home and an interior home are not the same conversation, so I would not blend them. I would watch pending activity within the same price tier, because that shows whether buyers are writing contracts for homes like mine. And I would pay attention to days on market within the relevant segment, not the citywide median.
I would watch price reductions, because that shows how other sellers are responding when their homes are not moving. I would watch condition and renovation differences, because visible maintenance or deferred repairs can separate two otherwise similar homes. And I would watch waterfront and lot characteristics, because the specific lake, frontage, dock, and setting can place a home in a completely different comp set.
I would also watch cross-shopping with Winter Garden and Dr. Phillips, because higher-end buyers often compare across market boundaries. The right comparison depends on what the same buyer can purchase for the money, including lot size, privacy, renovation level, community amenities, waterfront access, and architecture.
For Windermere, I would rather use a smaller set of genuinely comparable properties than a larger set that only shares the same city name. If you are weighing the cost of waiting, the carrying cost analysis puts a number on what every additional day on market actually costs. And if you are deciding whether to invest in the home before listing, the renovation framework explains how I think about improvements based on market impact rather than cost alone.
My takeaway for Windermere sellers
The question for a Windermere seller is not simply, what is the median price? The better question is, which homes are buyers actually comparing mine against?
The numbers in this report show that the inventory reaching contract is moving on a considerably shorter timeline than the active inventory still sitting. Active is at a median of 98.5 days, pending is at 42.5, and August closings closed at a median of 75 days. That gap tells me the homes getting accepted are positioned differently from the ones that keep sitting.
A report like this can tell you what is happening across the Windermere dataset. It cannot tell you where your home fits. That has to be worked out property by property, against the specific competition a buyer is actually choosing between. The general seller strategy page lays out how I approach that across different price tiers.
Thinking About Selling in Windermere?
Windermere is one of the markets where property-specific differences matter most. I look at the actual comp set, community, lake access, lot, condition, price tier, and active competition to show you where your property really sits.
The report gives you context. The real decision is where your specific property sits inside its competitive set, its price tier, and the property-specific factors a buyer is evaluating right now.
That is what the Seller Positioning Review works out. Your home, your comp set, your lake access and lot, your condition, and the position most likely to create buyer response.
Why is the $960,000 August median not a direct valuation for my Windermere home?
The $960,000 median is mathematically valid for the dataset, but the August closed-sale range ran from approximately $460,000 to $3.9 million. That range shows how broad the market is. Lakefront versus interior, community, lot type, condition, renovation level, and custom versus production construction can place two Windermere homes in completely different competitive sets. A citywide median provides context, but it should not be used as a direct valuation tool for an individual property.
What do the $2.5M+ counts tell us about the higher-end Windermere market?
The current dataset shows 51 active listings at $2.5 million and above, compared with 5 pending listings and 7 August closings. Those are the facts. They are not, by themselves, a conclusion that the segment is weak or oversupplied. What they do show is that higher-priced sellers should pay particular attention to the specific homes buyers are comparing, because broad citywide medians become less useful as properties become more unique.
How should I compare my Windermere home against Winter Garden and Dr. Phillips?
Higher-end buyers often compare across market boundaries. The right comparison depends on what the same buyer can purchase for the money, including lot size, privacy, renovation level, community amenities, waterfront access, and architecture. A Windermere home should be positioned against the alternatives the buyer is actually touring, not only against homes with the same city name.
Paulo Pereira
Paulo Pereira spent 5 years in hands-on apartment renovation work in New York City before entering residential real estate in 2011. His pre-listing review draws on that background to identify visible condition and presentation issues before they become part of the buyer's evaluation and due diligence.

